Community Trust Infrastructure · Open research

Research

OPEN RESEARCH · COMMUNITY TRUST INFRASTRUCTURE

Research programme

CTI is an open, technology-agnostic reference architecture for portable operational trust – not a deployed universal standard, blockchain, reputation score or claim that trust can be objectively computed. The research asks whether communities can carry forward evidence of real-world coordination without surrendering governance authority or creating a constant reporting burden.

Five core research questions

  • Can communities generate credible operational evidence as a low-burden byproduct of ordinary activity?
  • What validation and authorization conditions allow that evidence to be evaluated outside its originating context?
  • Can portable trust context reduce repeated proof costs while preserving privacy, autonomy and contestability?
  • Does access to community-generated evidence measurably change funder confidence or capital-allocation decisions?
  • Which functions generalize across communities, technologies and jurisdictions – and which remain relational or context-specific?

The research framework

Community activity → signals → attestations → validation → trust context → decision or policy interface → coordination or resource allocation.

This is a conceptual sequence, not a mandatory software pipeline. A verified record is not necessarily a valid interpretation, and a valid claim is not necessarily issued with legitimate authority. Financial execution and settlement remain outside the CTI trust layer.

Research tracks

1. Evidence, validation and governance

Study signal quality, provenance, steward confirmation, legitimate delegation, revocation, corrections and contestability. Test whether local communities can define what is recorded, disclosed and accepted without a central actor imposing a universal judgment.

2. Portability, privacy and proof cost

Investigate whether a structured trust context – claim, evidence references, validation procedure, governance provenance, limitations and disclosure permissions – can be reused across contexts. Compare reduced reporting effort against the full cost of verification, privacy, training, appeals and maintenance.

3. Philanthropic recognition and allocation

Test whether recognizing activity and coordination before a formal impact report changes funder decisions. Recognition is not the same as monetization or proof of outcomes; potential harms include surveillance, signal gaming and unequal participation.

4. AI, contribution recognition and resilience

Explore AI as an assistant for organizing and interpreting evidence, never as an independent source of governance authority. Investigate optional contribution-recognition mechanisms, human-led fallbacks, vendor replaceability and continuity when a steward or service provider exits.

Reference implementations and status

AIFS × Sarreya Tech365 — documented pilot observations

The 2025–2026 Somaliland pilot tested community activity records, WhatsApp-based Witness capture, attestations and financial access. Its internal team-review draft reports a workshop involving 31 women and community decisions on project spending. Lessons include the importance of relational off-ramps and community confirmation, alongside schema failures, gaps between declared and enforced signing authority, irreversible-transfer risk and privacy concerns. These are project observations, not independently audited impact findings or proof that CTI is validated.

SportFi and Ayni Skate Project — evaluation in progress / proposed tests

SportFi and the Bolivia community context are intended to test whether validated activity changes funder confidence, allocation decisions and portability across different governance and communication environments. No outcome is claimed in advance. Operational status should be checked against current project records before a result is published.

What would count as evidence?

  • Change in funder decisions attributable to community-generated evidence, compared with conventional reporting
  • Time and effort required to capture evidence and perform validation
  • Erroneous, contested, corrected or revoked attestations and the effectiveness of appeals
  • Legitimacy and actual technical enforcement of community-controlled authority
  • Cross-context implementation effort, maintenance cost, privacy protection and resilience to provider exit

Open questions and potential falsification

Can the architecture work without a trusted steward network? Can local authority and effective revocation survive portability? Do reporting savings exceed the total cost of stewardship? What happens when records are false, obsolete or unsafe to share? When do contribution incentives distort the activity being recognized? Negative findings are part of the research, not exceptions to be hidden.

Institutional comparison: World Bank FundsChain

FundsChain offers a comparison in transaction traceability and programmable financial controls. CTI asks a different question: whether the real-world evidence used to justify a decision has appropriate provenance, interpretation, authorization and community control. No interoperability between FundsChain and CTI is claimed; specific institutional implementation claims require primary-source verification.

Research method: from an observation to a defensible decision

CTI distinguishes three questions that are easily conflated: Did a record originate from an identifiable source and remain intact? Does the record support the meaning attributed to it? Was the person or process issuing or validating the claim legitimately authorized? A system may answer one without answering the others.

A proposed evidence record

  • Claim and context: what happened, when and where, with enough context to interpret the observation.
  • Provenance: who or what recorded it, what supporting artifacts exist and what limitations apply.
  • Attestation: who is prepared to make or confirm the claim, including the scope of their knowledge.
  • Validation and authority: how the claim was checked, who authorized the validator and whether that authority remains in force.
  • Disclosure and correction: what may be shared, what must remain private and how a disputed or obsolete record can be updated.
  • Decision boundary: what a receiving organization may infer and what additional judgment or due diligence remains necessary.

This is a conceptual research specification, not a finalized schema or assurance standard. Portability means carrying evidence and its qualifications forward; it does not require every recipient to reach the same conclusion.

Pilot evaluation: measures and comparison

The central SportFi test is not whether an attestation can be produced or a payment can be executed. It is whether usable, legitimately governed evidence changes a real decision without shifting unacceptable cost or risk onto the community.

Suggested evaluation dimensions

  • Evidence quality: completeness, corroboration, errors, disputed records and time to correction.
  • Governance integrity: traceable delegation, enforced signing rules, community control over disclosure and effective revocation.
  • Community burden: time spent recording activity, training, stewardship and responding to funder requests.
  • Funder decision effect: whether evidence changes confidence, timing, eligibility, conditions or amount of support, compared with ordinary reporting.
  • Portability: adaptation required in Bolivia or another community, including translation, bespoke engineering and local governance changes.
  • Continuity and safety: privacy incidents, provider dependencies, off-ramp availability and recovery if a maintainer exits.

These measures require baseline definitions, community consent, suitable comparison practices and transparent reporting of null or negative results. V2.2 proposes more than two weeks of bespoke engineering in the Bolivia setting as a practical warning signal, not a universal threshold.

Sarreya: what the difficult findings mean

Recognition and financial access are different problems

The pilot’s initial payment-speed framing did not capture the full difficulty. Access to an off-ramp depended on relationships, and community confirmation mattered to legitimacy. A faster settlement rail would not by itself have addressed either constraint.

A technically recorded claim can still fail

The team-review draft identified truncated IPFS identifiers, discrepancies between intended confirmation rules and deployed signing authority, and documentation that did not fully match implementation. These failures show why an immutable or signed record should not be mistaken for a complete assurance process.

Privacy, irreversibility and human stewardship matter

Publicly accessible participant images cannot necessarily be made private by revoking an attestation. An address-poisoning incident highlighted transfer risks. At the pilot’s scale, manual stewardship could be more appropriate than automation. These observations shape safeguards to investigate; their remediation status must be verified before claiming production readiness.

Limits of the current evidence

CTI V2.2 does not establish independent validation of pilot outcomes, a measured reduction in reporting cost, demonstrated changes in funder allocation, or successful portability across communities. The research programme is designed to make these propositions testable and contestable.

Exploratory research: financing long-term public sport infrastructure stewardship

Infrastructure investment creates long-term stewardship obligations that are frequently separated from the original capital funding decision. This research explores whether donor-retained capital and community-directed investment returns could help finance the ongoing maintenance, accessibility and programming of public sport infrastructure, while preserving municipal oversight and increasing transparency and community participation.

Research status: exploratory hypothesis, not an established financing model or CTI implementation. Investment custody, risk and return generation sit outside the CTI architecture; CTI could inform the evidence, authorization and accountability of allocation decisions. Legal, municipal governance, financial risk and operational feasibility require investigation. See the CTI research repository for ongoing research.

Research origins and opportunities for testing

This research has developed through work within All In For Sport (AIFS) and learning from collaborations with community partners, including Sarreya Sport. The pilot experiences provide early observations and important failure modes, not proof that the proposed CTI architecture works universally.

CTI is not limited to AIFS or to sport. Its research questions invite independent testing across community governance, evidence and verification, privacy, AI-assisted interpretation, coordination and capital allocation. Findings in these areas may also create opportunities for AIFS and other partners to design new experiments, compare approaches and challenge assumptions. Partner-specific findings remain subject to appropriate attribution, consent and review.

Read, examine and contribute

Read the public thesis, explore the reference architecture and experiments, consult the literature index, or challenge the assumptions and contribute. Source: CTI V2.2 public research edition, November 2026.

Exploratory research: recurring community-directed funding

Objective: The objective is not to make nonprofits better at competing for scarce operational funding. It is to investigate whether financial infrastructure can reduce the need for that competition altogether.

Research question: Can financial infrastructure enable recurring, community-directed funding from existing capital, reducing nonprofit dependence on competitive grants while preserving local decision-making authority?

Donor-retained capital and distributions of realized investment returns are one possible mechanism, not a validated implementation. Research will test funding predictability, reduced fundraising and administrative burdens, enforceable local authority, funding additionality, and investment and legal risks. Recurring returns are not guaranteed or necessarily distributable.

Infrastructure stewardship: Construction funding can leave municipalities with long-term safety, maintenance, accessibility and programming obligations. Research will compare supplementary committed distributions with conventional lifecycle reserves, while preserving municipal oversight.

CTI may support evidence, validation and accountable community allocation, but not custody, investment strategy or yield generation. Bread Cooperative and SportFi are exploratory reference cases, not proof of feasibility. Read the research note in the atlas.

Emerging research: capital ownership and community authority

Working hypothesis · November 2026. The source of capital need not automatically determine who makes downstream allocation decisions. CTI is investigating whether capital ownership, custody, investment management, allocation mandates and community decision-making can be separated while respecting legal and fiduciary responsibilities.

CTI does not manage assets or prescribe who governs. Its potential role is to make evidence, authorization, delegation and accountability legible to independent decision and payment systems. A key test is whether a community-authorized decision can be binding within an agreed mandate, even when a capital provider would have chosen differently.

Comparative research includes FASE Foundation as an emerging humanitarian-finance case, donor-retained capital and community-directed yield as a philanthropic hypothesis, and SportFi as a separate implementation research environment. No claim is made that these initiatives demonstrate effective community control, Canadian tax eligibility or durable financial returns. Read the working research note.